I recently went through the same delima, and decided on Duratrac's in 235/85r16. I have a 99 with 2.7l and 5spd. I am very happy with them so far. I have close to 3000 miles on them, mostly DD, but have seen some offroad, dirt, rocks, mud, etc, and they have handled all well. The road noise is very quiet for an offroad tire, the ride (and mine are E rated), is very good, handling is good. I run 32lbs, they ride nice. I can't comment on other 2 tires, as i have no experience with them. And gas mileage is good.
Hope this helps