Get the black If you don't mind cleaning it more then you'll drive it. Black is the nicest color on any car but mine, I'm to anal about keeping it clean and couldn't deal with it again. The blizzard pearl looks clean even when its dirty and really sparkles in the bright sun. If the runner came in a black metallic I would of had a real hard time (more then i already had because i was in the same boat as you) with the choice but the flat black just shows way to much dust, dirt, scratches and swirles (but it does look damn sexy). Good luck with your (wife's) choice.