You should second guess this. Saying 35 miles on a quarter tank was when reality kicked in doesn't make any sense. That statement tells you almost nothing about your gas mileage. I can go <25 miles and the gauge shows a 1/4 tank gone...that doesn't mean I get 100 miles on a tank (or have a gas leak). If you were to say 17mpg is too low and you need 30mpg, that's another story and totally understandable. Track your miles from fill-up, divide by gallons put in the next time, and you've got yourself a more accurate number.
Do you think I got less than 75 miles on this tank? Of course not. I got 77

:
Hope you line up a job soon. Unemployment can definitely suck.