The $250 is good price in my opinion. I had a much larger scratch from a very minor fender bender(woman claim she was reading direction from a printout and didn't see the car was stopped). Body shop total was about $480 including replacing the rubber stopper with the Toyota logo on the tow hitch. Her insurance paid for everything including a loaner Ford Edge for the 2 days in the shop. I think her car was a Corolla and had lot more damage than that. So I would take it to the place for $250.