Buy Toyota. Best looking and best quality. Paint em black if you want
I like the Toyota Wheels, I love my Sport Edition rims don't get me wrong. The problem with Toyota wheels is a couple fold.
-Toyota 4Runner & even FJ wheels are too close in terms of offset for larger tires
-Toyota does not make a 6x5.5 wheel that is wider than 7.5" (even the TRD Wheels)
-The TRD Trail wheels I linked earlier are amazing, well designed, and perfect for what I want, but offset, width, and the final clincher that makes me saddest is that they are ONLY availible in 16" for the 6x5.5 pattern. There are 17" & 18" Tundra wheels with the 5 lug, but I don't want to redrill them (would look tacky IMHO for the price spent on them) and I doubt Toyota would send me non-drilled wheels.
I actually chanced upon the Stealth 6's last night, does anyone know if they have meat in the outer rim for drilling/tapping a bead lock?
Those Methods look great, a few too many spokes for the style of wheel I like, but they fit my cosmetic requirements.
As I said before, the requirements I have for wheels is simple, yet apparently difficult to find...
-17-18" Diameter(I know I said 16 in the OP, but I had forgotten my Sport Edition won't fit 16's

)
- Anywhere between 8-9" wide rim
- Offset is tricky... I heard -2mm is equivilant to stock wheels +1.25" spacer and -12mm is good for wide rims...
-Either comes with a Beadlock or has enough meat in the outer edge to drill and tap for a beadlock
-Minimal to no chrome (that Dark/Smokey Chrome is exception, its grown on me...), no excessive fake nuts/rivets/whatever